Thank you Knoebels...
...for making an essentially perfect caramel apple and restoring my faith that there are still others out there who possess this deep and arcane knowledge.
First off, I just have to say what a great father's day it was with Jenn and Henry at Knoebels. After Jenn got me cool goodies from Woodcraft because she knows me sooooo well, the fam had a gut-bursting breakfast which we worked off on all kinds of kiddie-rides at the nation's largest free-admission park. Henry was in heaven and so was I and Jenn staged the perfect Father's Day. I felt like the biggest man around.
Second off (that was for you Kyle, if you're watching), I will now explain for all once *and once only* how the perfect caramel apple must be achieved:
1. start with an incredibly tart granny smith apple; anything else will be crap. You don't want it sweet or mushy. It has to be a crisp, violent-pucker-inducing apple the size of a baseball. Cheaping out on the apple is the worst sin of all. I submit that there is a special level of hell for any one who gets this wrong.
2. Apply a strong stick (3/8" diameter minimum) through the entire length of the core. This stick must stay in the apple even if an F5 tornado blows through, which coincidentally is equal to the force needed to bite into a caramel apple (get it? dentally?). See the previous comment about the importance of a crisp apple. It should be obvious that the right apple also helps in securing said apple to a huge stick that could double as a rake handle.
3. Dip apple in real hot caramel, not the fake junk, so that it forms a deep 1/4" covering EVENLY over the entire apple. We will say no more about the evil-doers who can't even bother to melt their caramel and use mystery-liquid-food-stuff-instead. But there should be no doubt about the importance of coverage: honestly, who can stand the amateurs who put the apple upside down and let the caramel cake on the top leaving an essentially bare apple behind. This is an insult that should not be endured : YOU should be dipped in hot caramel if you commit this sin.
4. Roll freshly dipped apple in nuts so liberally that at first sight you don't even see the caramel. DON'T wait for caramel to harden to do this.
5. Serve ASAP while caramel is luke warm.
FINAL PRODUCT: every bite must rake in gooey caramel, crunchy peanuts, and crisp, sweet-tart-like apple achieving ideal contrast and harmony simultaneously and setting off taste buds in your mouth you didn't know you had.
Knoebels nailed parts 1-4, which is extraordinary. Let's put it this way : I challenge you to remember the last time you met a caramel apple that even made it to part 1 successfully. And to give some credit, I sympathize that they have logistal issues to deal with and aren't in a position to hand dip right in front of you (IT CAN BE DONE, Knoebels - take that last step to caramel apple nirvanna). So there it is.